Pugsley Pizza in Bronx

Wow, just wow...This pizza place it's amazing, the pizza feels and taste like high qualityThe cannoli was deliciousTotally recommend this place

Wonderful place for spend time with family and friends and fabulous food everything is amazing I enjoy my time with my friend Sue we have wonderful day and people who work in is very friendly and cooool very lovely God Bless you all 💗🤗🥂🍾🙏💯💪💪💪💪🇮🇹🍷👍👍👍👍💯🍷🇮🇹💪

How lucky I was to be there by chance! The owner was very cheerful, and kind even to invite me and my granddaughter in making Pizza. All of my family enjoyed the experiences and ,of course, nice Pizza too.

My friend like jumped behind the counter and was ringing the bell like a captain abord a ship. i will say their garlic knots are top notch!

What a pizza restaurant 😁 very recommanded!

This Hidden Gem of a Pizza shop is located between Fordham University & Fordham Rd and boy what an at home warm feeling when you enter, Sal welcomes you like he's know you for years and if your lucky he'll let you hit the Gong behind the Counter. Great Pizza and Food in General, staff is amazing. If your in the area its def worth a visit, and most of all don't forget to bring your appetite...

So. Damn. Good.Authentic Italian pizza from two lovely Italians! The sauce is delicious. They make their own spicy sauce that goes over the top which makes it so good it hurts (if you're into spicy).

Wow! A super find, one of the most unforgettable pizza experiences. Sal and Pina are a wonderful couple and make you feel right at home. And the pizza is wonderful. Would give six stars if I could!

You won't find a better pica place in the area. Amazing service and even more amazing food. Hoghly recommend it.

This is a good slice of pizza. The ingredients are fresh. The crust is both a little chewy and crispy. The cheese and sauce ratio is perfect. Good all around slice and the vibe in restaurant is chill-laxed.

First time visiting this restaurant. Pleasantly surprised. Small in capacity with a very unique setting. Great staff. I had a super-sized, mouthwatering, scrumptious, melt-in-your-mouth pizza with extra cheese and sausage. It was g-r-e-a-t! Good food at low prices. Well worth visiting.

place is cozy, but the pizza itself is overrated - there's much better in nyc

One of the few pizzreas that I will go out of my way to get to. Great taste, great value, great atmosphere. They are open late, they have alcohol and take cards.

If you are looking for an authentic, Italian, New York pizza experience, you just can’t go wrong with Pugsley. The slices are generous, the homemade sauce delicious, and the crust divine. We recently stumbled across Pugsley and we will definitely be going back the next time we are in the Bronx.

good location! The owner is great!

Pugsleys has very nice employees, a lively indoor setting, and some really amazing food. Seriously.. I was truly amazed at how perfect the crust on that pie was.

Feel like home environment and outstanding home made food, great spot to eat while you're near the Botanical Gardens, just saying.

Here the ambience is better than the food unfortunately. The slices are comically large and lacking in flavor. I added pineapple to mine and even though I love pineapple pizza, their version seemed like the pineapple was added on as an afterthought. The restaurant itself is lively with lots of local college students. Sal is also great and worth visiting to meet him alone.

Great prices, great service, great food. Whats not 2 love?

Disclaimer: I'm rating only the pizza. Without a doubt, the best traditional NY slice I've tried! Creamy and delicious. I can tell they use fresh cheese and they care about the making. Also tried the meat lovers but didn't like it as much as the simple cheese one. The place can use a little cleaning, but other than that, the guys are super nice and have a nice selections of condiments.

AWESOME Hidden Little Spot The Pizza Is Amazing The Pasta Well Pretty Much Everything. THEY Will Also Teach You Hands On To Make Your Pizza If You Choose On The House Cant Go Wrong With The Place

Loved the old style decor. Very homey feeling.

Awesome slices. Late hours. Food quality is very good here, flavorful as well. Chicken bacon ranch slice is outstanding especially with some garlic powder. Prices are food, cheaper with cash thn credit card $10 min on card. ATM on premises.

This was the best family pizza experience I've ever had. The owner Sal opened up 15 minutes early for us because we were waiting with 4 kids 4 and under.He have them each pizza dough to play with and showed them how to make pizza. Our food was as fresh as it can be and then out of no where Sal came out okaying a saxphone with a giant sparkler in it.My kids loved every second of it. The best service I've ever had.

Probably some of the best pizza and service around. Always an immediate recommendation for anyone in the area or passing near the Fordham U campus

Great Bronx pizzeria!

Timeless place. Amazing pizza and chicken rolls. The owner Sal and his family are so friendly.

Great Pizza, great ambient, family friendly and entertaining😁

I admire this place! They serve good meals, they have a nice menu, The cook in that restaurant is a professional, I love very much eating all their food. The food is consistently good, the attitude towards the visitors is efficient. I often go to this restaurant and I not even once was discontended. I recommend it with no hesitation.

You will be happier having eaten here!Sal has created here a warm cozy atmosphere that is as amazing as you allow it to be. His menu only offers what he loves to make. Food for him is an expression of love; his words.Of course the Fordham brand is represented. During the school year the hours are 11am-5am, Summer hours are 11am-7pm.The entrance is out of the way, as it should be. Finding it is a reward for your effort.Only bring fun, creative people here!

Best pizza in the bronx hands down

Great pizza and a cool outside sitting area. Pugsley Pizza is a hidden local gem with an assortment of great combos at a good price. The Pizza is delicious, one of the best in the area, and the pitchers of beer are really cheap.

So good to see Sal still working here. He's an institution as much as Fordham. Food is just as good as I remember. Chicken rolls are amazing as well as the slices. Can't go wrong here.

Awesome spot! Great people who love what they're doing

Felt welcomed, pizza was good but the price was a little high (3.00 per slice)

Saw pictures and reviews of this place and it all looked so great. I ordered a large thin crust with extra cheese and got a doughy thick pie with barely any cheese. Pizza was mediocre. Not worth the hype. "Best hidden pizzeria"?? I'm sorry but it should stay hidden.

Pugsley's Pizza is a Bronx hidden gem! The owner and his family are so warm and welcoming. Let's not forget that the food is delicious! It has that favorite college main stay regardless of your age. If you are ever in the area stop by and just experience it for yourself.

Pugsley is a great local place for pizza and is the go to pizza place for Fordham University students. I love their chicken rolls as well as their pizza.

One of the best pizzerias in NYC, combines great pizza with delightful atmosphere. If you're lucky, Sal will play his sax for you. (If you're unlucky, you'll have the life scared out of you by the gong....)

Pugsley's is one of the best in the bronx

Excellent and delicious food made with true love. A place to go and will absolutely enjoy. I love Pugsley Pizza!!! 😍😍 You have to try! Will be back for more!

I don't do five star reviews, but the pizza, the service and the ambiance here - on a take out order during a global pandemic- was phenomenal. Sal is a true gentleman. The pizza is phenomenal. Can't wait to go back.

Great pizza and other Italian specialties made with LOVE. Sal makes you feel at home. Treats children special and makes them laugh. Decor is flashback 80's but you've got to respect a place with a gong behind the counter. Besides, you're not there for the decor: eat the pizza!

Best Fordham student pizza place

The pizza and other food is dynamite! Sal and family make it with love. Keep playing the sax Sal.

We like a lot going out. Yesterday we went to this delicious place which friends told us about. We passed a lovely experience there with fine meal and a nice stuff and a professional chef. We added this fine restaurant in our phone list and we shall definitely visit again very soon. We warmly recommend.

Best Pizza spot in the Bronx , No matter what it is, Hands down Pugsleys Pizza has you covered !!! #LoveIsIt

Wonderful pizza, colorful staff and homey atmosphere

Might just have been the best slice of pizza I have ever had growing up in NY. From the sauce to the dough. Everything was amazing!